Skip to content
Mango & Co

Managed VA, freelancer or UK hire: which is right for you?

There are three ways to get help with the admin that eats your week, and each is the right answer for somebody. This compares them on what actually decides it: who finds the person, who carries the risk, and what happens when something goes wrong.

Martyn Butler, founder · Updated 24 September 2026 · 6 minute read

The short answer

Choose a freelancer if you have managed people before, have time to recruit and want the lowest hourly cost. Choose a UK hire for work that needs somebody in the room or the whole UK day, and budget for employer National Insurance at 15% on pay above £5,000. Choose a managed VA for repeatable work on a screen, when you want someone else to carry recruiting, pay, cover and replacement.

The three options

  • A freelance VA: somebody you find and engage directly, often through a job board or marketplace.
  • A managed VA: a VA recruited, contracted, paid and supervised by a company like ours, working for you.
  • A UK hire: an employee on your payroll, in the office or at home.

Side by side

Freelance VAManaged VAUK hire
Who finds and vets themYouThe providerYou, or a recruiter
Who holds the contract and pays themYouThe providerYou, through payroll
Cover when they are offYour problemArranged by the providerYour problem
If it does not work outYou start againThe provider replaces themA process, then you start again
Day-to-day directionYouYou, with supportYou
Employer National InsuranceNoneNone: it is the provider's fee15% on pay above £5,000, up from 13.8% in April 2025
Sick payYou pay for hours workedDepends on the provider (with us, paid sick days are in the monthly price)Statutory sick pay, from you
Employment disputesLow, if they are genuinely self-employedNot with you: they are contracted to the providerYours, including tribunal risk
Cost per hourLowestHigher than freelance, well below UKHighest

When a freelancer is the right answer

If you have hired and managed people before, have time to recruit properly, and want the lowest hourly cost, go direct. You carry the vetting, the contract, the pay and the risk of starting again, and for plenty of owners that is a fair trade.

When a UK hire is the right answer

Some work needs somebody in the room: viewings, inspections, a front desk. Some needs the whole UK working day with no gap. Some is regulated in ways that make an offshore arrangement hard. For that work, hire in the UK, and do it with the full cost in view: salary, employer National Insurance (15% on pay above £5,000 since April 2025), pension, holiday, statutory sick pay and cover, the time it takes to recruit, and the risk of a tribunal if it goes wrong.

When a managed VA is the right answer

If the work is repeatable and done on a screen, and you want it done without becoming a recruiter and an HR department, a managed VA sits between the two. You direct the work; somebody else carries the recruiting, the contract, the pay, the cover and the replacement.

What to ask any provider

  • How do you test people before I meet them?
  • Who is the VA's contract with, and who pays them?
  • What happens when they are ill or on holiday?
  • What happens if it is not working after a month?
  • Who owns the procedures we write together, if the VA leaves?
  • When do I pay, and what am I committed to?

Common questions

What is a managed virtual assistant?

A managed VA is recruited, contracted, paid and supervised by a provider, and works for you. You direct the day-to-day work, with support; the provider carries the recruiting, the contract, the pay, cover when they are off, and a replacement if it does not work out. It costs more per hour than a freelancer, and well below a UK hire.

Is a managed VA cheaper than hiring in the UK?

Yes: per hour, a managed VA costs well below a UK hire, though more than a freelancer. A UK hire also brings employer National Insurance at 15% on pay above £5,000, pension, holiday, statutory sick pay and cover, the time it takes to recruit, and the risk of a tribunal. With a managed VA there is no employer National Insurance for you to pay.

Do I have to pay sick pay to a virtual assistant?

Only if they are your employee. A UK hire gets statutory sick pay from you. A freelancer is paid for the hours they work, so there is no sick pay to find. With a managed VA it depends on the provider; with us, their paid sick days are in the monthly price, so you pay nothing extra.

What happens if a VA does not work out?

It depends who holds the contract. With a freelancer, you start again yourself. With a UK hire, there is a process to follow before you start again, and any employment dispute is yours, including the risk of a tribunal. With a managed VA, the provider replaces them, and because the VA is contracted to the provider, a dispute is not with you.

What should I ask a VA provider?

Ask how they test people before you meet them, who holds the VA's contract and pays them, and what happens when the VA is ill or on holiday. Then ask what happens if it is not working after a month, who owns the procedures you write together if the VA leaves, and when you pay and what you are committed to.